A shared copy is not an approved version

Keep the origin, changes and review status attached when AI-assisted work moves between tools.

Original paper-cut illustration of three cream folders holding different teal and amber kite designs, with three navy laptops, a pencil and binder clip on a warm desk.
Original conceptual illustration.
Watch the 42-second shared-copy lesson

The newest attachment can still be the wrong one

Imagine a fictional community workshop making paper kites. One person writes the instructions, another asks AI to shorten them, and a third creates a printable handout. By the end of the afternoon, three files have similar names. The most recently received attachment looks polished. Nobody is sure whether it includes the author's correction.

This is a small coordination problem with a surprisingly important question: which version are we actually reviewing? Sharing a file makes it available. It does not tell the next person where it came from, what changed or whether someone approved those changes.

Give the copy a history

W3C's PROV-Overview, published as a Working Group Note on April 30, 2013, describes provenance as information about the things, activities and people involved in producing something. The PROV document family supports exchanging that history across systems. The overview is non-normative guidance, not a new AI benchmark or a finding from Ben's research.

For a beginner, the useful starting point is not a complicated database. It is a short note attached to the work: this copy came from that version; this person or tool made these changes; this review is still outstanding. The exercise below is an original practical interpretation, not a claim of PROV compliance.

Try a two-copy handoff

Start with a harmless paragraph you wrote about folding a decorative paper kite. Keep it free of private names, customer information and confidential methods. Save an original copy called “kite-guide-01.” Ask an AI tool to suggest a shorter version without adding supplies or changing the order of the steps.

Save that suggestion separately as “kite-guide-02-draft.” Alongside it, record the original filename, the request you made and the tool you used. Add a plain-language status: “AI-assisted rewrite; not yet reviewed.” Do not let a neat layout or a confident answer silently turn that draft into approved instructions.

Now compare the two copies. Suppose the rewrite removes a step about marking the fold. Restore it if it is necessary, then record your reason. The next copy should identify both its starting point and the human correction. A filename alone is not enough if the content can change without a corresponding update.

Check the handoff, not just the upload

Before another person uses the guide, ask them to identify the version, the change and the reviewer from the package itself. They should not need your memory of the chat. If they cannot find those details, repair the note before making more copies.

For this fictional exercise, an approval might say: “Reviewed for the indoor paper-folding demonstration on November 13.” That is narrower than “approved for everything.” A later outdoor activity, different materials or a different audience could require another review. Keep the earlier record instead of rewriting history to make every copy look current.

This example is about coordination across people and tools. It is not a federated-learning experiment, and it does not demonstrate that a distributed AI system has become safer.

Make your contribution visible

In a knowledge portfolio, retain the starting paragraph, the AI suggestion and your final decision note. Separate the model's wording from your judgment about what the learner needs. That distinction connects attribution with governance: understanding a contribution is different from authorizing a particular use.

BenHarvey.ai's current attribution and distributed-AI programs include proposals and evaluation plans; they do not establish a completed federated-learning benchmark. This exercise offers a working habit, not a promise of legal protection, licensing income or employment.

Before your next handoff, add three lines: where this copy came from, what changed, and what review it has actually received. A useful copy carries its history with it.

More from the blog RSS feed